Listen up, NFL general managers, because I’m about to drop some wisdom that’ll save you from another decade of mediocrity and fanbase meltdowns. You know that shiny top-10 draft pick you’re clutching like a golden ticket? Don’t blow it on a quarterback. Seriously, just don’t. Let the New York Jets take that gamble for you—they’ve been perfecting the art of quarterback flops since Mark Sanchez was eating hot dogs on the sideline. Instead, sit back, build your team, and swoop in three or four years later to snag their discarded “franchise savior” for pennies on the dollar. It’s the ultimate heist, and the Jets are the gift that keeps on giving.
Take a gander at Sam Darnold’s 2024 season with the Minnesota Vikings. The guy was the third overall pick in 2018, hand-picked by the Jets to be their next Joe Namath. Spoiler alert: he wasn’t. In three years with Gang Green, Darnold threw 45 touchdowns and 39 interceptions, posting a pedestrian 78.3 passer rating while looking perpetually confused by Adam Gase’s playcalling—if you can even call it that. The Jets couldn’t develop him, couldn’t protect him, and couldn’t win with him, finishing with a 13-25 record in his starts. Fast forward to 2024, and Darnold lands in Minnesota on a measly one-year, $10 million deal. What happens? The dude explodes—nearly 3,300 passing yards, 28 touchdowns, and a 68.4% completion rate through 13 games, dragging the Vikings to an 11-2 record. He even earned a Pro Bowl nod. Same Sam Darnold, different team, totally different outcome. The Jets didn’t ruin his talent; they just had no clue how to unlock it.
Then there’s Geno Smith, another Jets castoff who’s been making Seattle fans forget Russell Wilson ever existed. Drafted 39th overall in 2013—not quite top-10, but close enough for this argument—Smith was supposed to be the Jets’ future. Instead, he was a punching bag, both figuratively and literally (remember that locker room jaw incident?). In four seasons with New York, he went 12-18 as a starter, with 28 touchdowns and 36 picks, and a cringe-worthy 72.3 passer rating. The Jets dumped him, and after bouncing around as a backup, he landed with the Seahawks in 2019. By 2022, he was their starter, and oh boy, did he deliver: a league-leading 69.8% completion rate, 4,282 yards, 30 touchdowns, and a Pro Bowl nod. In 2023, he kept it rolling, and in 2024, he finished fourth in passing yards (over 4,000) and fifth in completion percentage (67.4%), despite throwing 15 picks. Over three years as Seattle’s QB1, he’s gone 25-23, a far cry from the Jets’ mess. The scouts saw the arm talent and poise in both Darnold and Smith—too bad the Jets couldn’t.
Here’s the kicker: NFL scouts are damn good at their jobs. They can spot a quarterback’s potential from a mile away—arm strength, pocket presence, the works. Darnold had it at USC. Smith had it at West Virginia. The problem isn’t the scouting; it’s the teams—specifically, the Jets—who take these raw talents and turn them into cautionary tales. Crumbling offensive lines, clueless coaching staffs, and a culture of losing don’t just stunt growth—they torch it. The Jets have cycled through Sanchez (5th overall, 2009), Smith, Darnold, and Zach Wilson (2nd overall, 2021), racking up a combined 154 touchdowns to 160 interceptions with a 73.6 rating during their tenures. That’s not a quarterback problem; that’s a Jets problem.
So why waste your precious top-10 pick on a QB when you can let the Jets do the scouting, suffer the growing pains, and then swoop in like a vulture after they inevitably cut bait? Build your roster first—shore up that O-line, grab a stud receiver, tighten your defense. Look at the Vikings and Seahawks: both had solid pieces in place when Darnold and Smith arrived. Minnesota had Justin Jefferson and a top-tier offensive mind in Kevin O’Connell. Seattle had DK Metcalf, Tyler Lockett, and a culture Pete Carroll had spent years crafting. The Jets? They had… well, a cool logo, I guess.
The beauty of this strategy is it’s low-risk, high-reward. Darnold’s cap hit in 2024 was $5 million—chump change compared to the $44.5 million Geno’s set to cost Seattle in 2025 (a number they’ll likely rework). You’re not tied to a bloated rookie contract or a desperate trade. You grab a guy who’s been humbled, seasoned, and—crucially—still has the talent the scouts drooled over. Meanwhile, the Jets keep spinning their wheels, drafting the next big thing only to watch him wilt under their dysfunction.
So, NFL teams, take my advice: skip the quarterback roulette in the top 10. Let the Jets play their losing game, and then cherry-pick their scraps a few years down the line. Build a real team, not a quarterback shrine. Because if history’s any indication, the Jets will keep handing you diamonds—they just won’t know how to polish them. You’re welcome.
Leave a comment