In a move that’s got more twists than a Vegas magic show, the New York Rangers traded forward Reilly Smith to the Vegas Golden Knights on Thursday, March 6, 2025, for prospect Brendan Brisson and a 2025 third-round pick (originally San Jose’s, because who doesn’t love a draft pick with a travel history?). With the NHL trade deadline ticking down to 3 PM ET tomorrow, March 7, both teams are clearly gunning for playoff glory—though their strategies look as different as a Broadway ballad and a slot machine jingle. Let’s break down how this swap helps each contender in their quest for Lord Stanley’s shiny mug, with a few chuckles along the way.
Vegas Golden Knights: The Misfit Returns to the Desert
Reilly Smith is back in Vegas, and it’s like the Golden Knights are throwing a reunion party for their 2023 Stanley Cup champs—except this time, they’re hoping he brings more than just fond memories and a killer playlist. Smith, a 33-year-old winger with 10 goals and 29 points in 58 games this season, knows the Vegas system better than a blackjack dealer knows when you’re bluffing. He spent six seasons with the Knights (2017-23), racking up 124 goals (third in franchise history) and hoisting the Cup two years ago with 14 playoff points in 22 games. This isn’t just a nostalgia grab—it’s a calculated boost for a team sitting pretty atop the Pacific Division with 80 points (37-18-6).
For Vegas, Smith fills a gaping hole: depth scoring on the wing. With injuries piling up—William Karlsson’s on LTIR with a $5.9 million cap hit, and Raphael Lavoie just left a game against Toronto with an upper-body ouchie—the Knights needed a reliable forward who doesn’t need a GPS to find the net. Smith’s two shorthanded goals this year (tied for second on the Rangers) and his 106 playoff games of experience make him a Swiss Army knife for Bruce Cassidy’s lineup. Coach Cassidy practically did a happy dance, saying, “He’s a veteran guy, he knows how we play, he knows the room, and he knows our expectations.” Translation: Smith’s the guy you call when you need someone to kill a penalty, score a timely goal, and not freak out when the postseason pressure hits.
With the Rangers retaining 50% of Smith’s $3.75 million cap hit (down to a cool $1.875 million for Vegas), the Knights sneak him in under their $6.4 million cap cushion—though they’re now down to about $500K unless Karlsson’s out for the season. It’s a tight squeeze, but Smith’s return gives Vegas four solid lines without relying on AHL call-ups. He’s not the 60-point dynamo from 2017-18 anymore, but he’s a postseason-proven piece who could be the difference between a first-round exit and another Cup parade down the Strip. Plus, he might even convince the team mascot to ditch the Elvis wig for a game or two.
New York Rangers: Youth, Picks, and a Playoff Prayer
Meanwhile, on the other side of the trade, the Rangers are playing a different game—one part youth movement, one part asset hoarding, and three parts “please, let us make the playoffs.” Sitting at 31-26-5 with 67 points, they’re clinging to third in the Eastern Conference Wild Card race like a tourist clutching their last subway token. Trading Smith, a pending UFA they weren’t going to re-sign, for Brendan Brisson and a high third-round pick (thanks, basement-dwelling Sharks!) is GM Chris Drury’s way of saying, “We’re not done yet, but we’re also not betting the farm.”
Brisson, a 23-year-old center/winger and Vegas’s 2020 first-round pick (No. 29 overall), is the wildcard here. His NHL stat line—two goals and eight points in 24 games—won’t make you spill your coffee, and his minus-24 rating with AHL Henderson this season (5-14-19 in 45 games) suggests he’s been less “future star” and more “where’s the exit?” lately. But the Rangers see upside. His 38 points in 52 AHL games last year and a sparkling 21-21-42 at Michigan in 2021-22 hint at potential. Assigned to Hartford, Brisson joins a youth brigade—Brett Berard, Brennan Othmann, and others—vying for call-up duty. If he rediscovers his scoring touch, he could be a cheap, controllable depth piece (he’s an RFA this summer) for a playoff run—or at least a fun experiment while the Rangers figure out their forward lines.
The third-round pick sweetens the pot. With San Jose tanking harder than a reality TV contestant, it’s likely an early third-rounder—perfect for drafting a future gem or flipping in another deal. Drury’s stockpiling assets like a squirrel prepping for winter, having already moved UFAs Ryan Lindgren and Jimmy Vesey to Colorado earlier this week for picks and players. With nearly $17 million in cap space (per PuckPedia) even after retaining half of Smith’s salary, the Rangers have room to maneuver before tomorrow’s deadline—maybe snagging a scorer or a defenseman to bolster their shaky 2.86 goals-against average.
Smith’s exit opens ice time for the kids, which could ignite a spark in a lineup that’s been inconsistent offensively. The Rangers aren’t all-in rentals like Vegas; they’re balancing a playoff push with a mini-retool. If Brisson pans out and the pick becomes a player, this trade could look brilliant in hindsight—or at least keep fans from rioting in Madison Square Garden when the inevitable “Fire Drury” chants start.
The Playoff Payoff: Two Paths, One Goal
For Vegas, Smith’s return is about stacking the deck (pun intended) for another deep playoff run. He’s not the flashiest card, but he’s an ace up Cassidy’s sleeve—reliable, versatile, and ready to shine when the lights get bright. The Knights are contenders now, and this move screams, “We’re not messing around.”
For the Rangers, it’s a calculated risk with an eye on both spring and summer. Brisson and the pick give them flexibility, while freeing up Smith’s minutes might just unleash a young gun to carry them into the postseason. They’re contenders too—just the kind that’s still figuring out if they’re starring in Hamilton or Groundhog Day.
In the end, this trade is a win-win with a side of “what if?” Vegas gets tougher, New York gets younger, and we all get to watch the playoff drama unfold. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’m off to bet on whether Smith scores the Cup-winner or Brisson accidentally photobombs a Rangers press conference. Place your bets, hockey fans—it’s deadline season!
Leave a comment