Let’s talk about our boy Brock Purdy. The Cinderella story of the NFL—a seventh-round pick turned Super Bowl starter, the darling of San Francisco, and the guy who made “Mr. Irrelevant” sound like a superhero alias. But as the 2025 offseason looms, the big question is: does this guy deserve a $50 million-a-year paycheck? Spoiler alert: I’m not buying it, and neither should the Niners—at least not yet. Let’s break it down, sprinkle in some Patrick Mahomes shade for perspective, and figure out why it’s time to pump the brakes on handing Purdy a blank check.
The 2024 Slide: Injuries or Excuses?
Last year, Purdy’s stat line took a bit of a nosedive, and not in the “oh, he’s just setting up for a dramatic comeback” kind of way. In 2023, he was the golden child—fourth in MVP voting, slinging touchdowns like a budget Tom Brady, and leading the 49ers to the Super Bowl. Fast forward to 2024: the dude regressed. His interception rate ticked up (2.6% from 2.5%—not massive, but still a buzzkill), his efficiency dipped, and the Niners finished a measly 6-11. Sure, the injury gods turned San Francisco into a MASH unit—Christian McCaffrey, Brandon Aiyuk, Trent Williams, you name it, they were sidelined. But here’s the rub: great QBs elevate, not evaporate, when the going gets tough. Purdy? He looked more like a deer in headlights than a franchise savior.
Compare that to Patrick Mahomes, the Chiefs’ $450 million wizard. Kansas City’s offense isn’t exactly a murderers’ row of talent—sorry, Rashee Rice, you’re no Tyreek Hill—but Mahomes still conjures magic out of thin air. Why? Because he’s worth every penny of that obscene contract. Purdy, meanwhile, leaned hard on Kyle Shanahan’s system and a stacked roster in his good years. Take away the toys, and suddenly he’s not looking like a $50 million QB—he’s looking more like a $50 gift card to Chili’s. Decent, but not life-changing.
The Chiefs Conundrum: When You Pay Big, You Lose Big (Weapons)
Speaking of Mahomes, let’s take a peek at life in Kansas City. That 10-year, $450 million deal (averaging $45 million annually) sounds dreamy, right? Well, it’s a double-edged sword. The Chiefs have had to wave bye-bye to studs like Tyreek Hill and Orlando Brown because cap space vanishes faster than free snacks at a Super Bowl party when your QB’s eating up 16% of the pie. Mahomes makes it work because he’s a freak—scrambling, improvising, turning fourth-and-forever into highlight reels. But even he can’t hide the fact that the Chiefs’ offense lacks the firepower it once had. Now imagine the 49ers shelling out $50 million a year for Purdy. Say goodbye to Deebo Samuel, George Kittle, or maybe even Nick Bosa. Good luck winning with a QB who’s still figuring out how to throw in the rain and a roster that’s suddenly bargain-bin deep.
Timing Is Everything: Don’t Pay Him Yet!
Here’s the kicker: Purdy’s still on his rookie deal through 2025. Why on earth would the 49ers rush to pay him now? Let him play out his contract year! This isn’t a fairy tale where you crown the prince before he slays the dragon—it’s the NFL, where you earn your stripes. Unless Purdy comes out in 2025 looking like he’s channeling prime Joe Montana (and not just because they share a jersey number), the Niners should hold off. If he balls out, great—negotiate then. If he flops again, well, maybe it’s time to see if he can hack it without Shanahan’s playbook and a Pro Bowl supporting cast.
The Team-Friendly Deal or Bust
Let’s say Purdy does improve in 2025—throws for 4,000 yards, cuts the picks, wins a playoff game or two. Even then, $50 million feels like highway robbery. That’s Mahomes money, Josh Allen money, Lamar Jackson money—guys who can carry a team on their back, not just ride the coattails of a genius coach and All-Pro talent. Purdy’s worth $39-43 million tops. Think of it like this: $50 million buys you a yacht; $40 million gets you a really nice boat with a solid motor. Purdy’s the latter—reliable, functional, but not exactly screaming luxury.
If he’s not willing to take that team-friendly deal, let him walk! Seriously, wave bye-bye and see how he fares with a lesser coach—say, whoever’s unlucky enough to be coaching the Raiders next—and a roster that doesn’t read like an NFC Pro Bowl ballot. My guess? He’d be exposed faster than a TikTok dance trend. Shanahan’s system is the secret sauce; without it, Purdy might just be a slightly above-average QB with a knack for timing.
Final Take: Don’t Break the Bank for Brock
Look, I get it—Purdy’s a feel-good story, and he’s done some great things for the 49ers. But $50 million a year? That’s like tipping 50% on a mediocre meal because the waiter smiled at you. The Niners need to play hardball here. Let 2025 be his prove-it year. If he lights it up, offer him $39-43 million and keep the roster intact. If he balks, let him test the market and watch some desperate team overpay for a guy who’s more system than superstar. Either way, San Francisco wins—either with a cost-controlled QB or by dodging a bullet. Brock, buddy, you’re good, but you’re not that good. Not yet, anyway.
Leave a comment