It’s official: Sam Darnold’s one-year stint with the Minnesota Vikings is over. After a breakout 2024 season that saw him lead the team to a 14-3 record, earn a Pro Bowl nod, and guide the Vikings to the playoffs, the franchise has opted not to use the franchise tag, letting him hit free agency as of March 10. The news, confirmed by ESPN’s Adam Schefter, marks the end of a surprising chapter in Minneapolis—one that turned a supposed bridge quarterback into a legitimate starter. But as Darnold packs his bags, questions swirl: Where will he land next? Was his purple-and-gold success a fluke? And can rookie J.J. McCarthy step up to keep the Vikings rolling? Let’s dive in.
The Viking Farewell
Darnold’s 2024 campaign was nothing short of a revelation. Signed to a one-year, $10 million deal in March 2024, he was meant to hold the fort while first-round pick J.J. McCarthy developed. But when McCarthy tore his meniscus in the preseason, Darnold seized the opportunity. He threw for 4,319 yards, 35 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions, finishing with a 103.4 passer rating—career highs across the board. His 14-3 record as a starter tied the Vikings with the Detroit Lions atop the NFC North, though a 27-9 wild-card loss to the Los Angeles Rams ended their postseason run. Despite the late-season stumble—five interceptions in his final two games—Darnold’s body of work was impressive enough to spark debate about his future in Minnesota.
Yet, the Vikings’ decision not to tag him at a projected $41.3 million cap hit signals their commitment to McCarthy, the No. 10 overall pick in the 2024 draft. With $57 million in cap space (fifth-most in the NFL), they could’ve kept Darnold, but GM Kwesi Adofo-Mensah and head coach Kevin O’Connell seem ready to bet on their young quarterback’s potential over Darnold’s proven production. It’s a bold move—and one that leaves Darnold free to cash in elsewhere.
Where Will Darnold Go?
As the top quarterback available in free agency, Darnold won’t lack suitors. At 27, with a fresh resume of success, he’s poised for a multi-year deal in the $30-40 million annual range—think Baker Mayfield’s three-year, $100 million contract with Tampa Bay as a benchmark. Here are the most likely landing spots:
- Las Vegas Raiders: Fresh off a 2-14 season, the Raiders are desperate for a quarterback upgrade. With $95 million in cap space and new head coach Pete Carroll—a fellow USC alum—Darnold could be a perfect fit. Posts on X and reports from insiders like Adam Schefter suggest Vegas will be in the mix, especially with their reluctance to draft a QB early in recent years.
- Pittsburgh Steelers: ESPN’s Seth Walder pegged Pittsburgh as a prime destination, citing their strong defense, Mike Tomlin’s winning culture, and lack of a top draft pick to land a rookie. Darnold could thrive with weapons like George Pickens and a stout run game.
- New York Jets: A long-shot full-circle story, floated by Bleacher Report’s Kris Knox. Darnold’s 2018-2020 tenure with the Jets was rocky (13-25 as a starter), but a reunion could make sense if they view him as a reclamation success under better coaching and support.
The Raiders and Steelers feel most plausible, given their immediate needs and resources. Wherever he lands, Darnold’s next contract will dwarf his Minnesota paycheck.
Fluke or Foundation?
Was Darnold’s 2024 season a one-off, propped up by Kevin O’Connell’s quarterback-friendly system and stars like Justin Jefferson? Or can he carry this success forward? The truth lies in between. His 67.9% completion rate and 8.2 yards per attempt were career bests, but he’d shown flashes before—think his 2022 stint with Carolina (4-2 as a starter, 92.6 rating). In Minnesota, he benefited from elite playmakers (Jefferson, Jordan Addison, T.J. Hockenson) and a top-10 defense that kept games manageable. His late-season struggles—11.1% of his passes intercepted in the final two games versus 2.5% earlier—echoed past inconsistency with the Jets and Panthers.
That said, Darnold’s growth in decision-making and pocket presence was real. O’Connell’s coaching elevated him, much like it did Kirk Cousins, suggesting he’s not just a system product. If he lands with a competent offense—say, Pittsburgh’s or Vegas’s with the right moves—his success could translate. It’s not guaranteed, but 2024 proved he’s no fluke when given the right tools.
Can McCarthy Pick Up the Torch?
Enter J.J. McCarthy, the wildcard in this equation. The 22-year-old missed his entire rookie season after knee surgery, a rare setback for a first-round quarterback since the NFL’s modern draft era began in 1967. Despite glowing reports from training camp—where he trailed Darnold but showed promise—his lack of game reps raises questions. O’Connell has praised McCarthy’s rehab progress, noting he’s “right where we hoped” and set for a full offseason. GM Adofo-Mensah echoed confidence in his work ethic, though he admitted uncertainty about his readiness.
McCarthy’s college tape at Michigan (27-1 as a starter, national title in 2023) screams potential, but his pro transition hinges on health and adaptation. The Vikings’ infrastructure—O’Connell’s play-calling, a stacked offense—mirrors what fueled Darnold’s success. If McCarthy’s knee holds up and he absorbs the mental reps from 2024, he could thrive. But matching Darnold’s 14 wins and 4,319 yards in Year 1 off a lost season? That’s a tall order. History offers little precedent, making this a leap of faith for Minnesota.
Final Thoughts
Sam Darnold’s departure leaves the Vikings at a crossroads, betting on McCarthy’s upside over a known commodity. For Darnold, free agency opens a new chapter—likely with a fat paycheck and a chance to prove 2024 was no mirage. The Raiders or Steelers could be his next proving ground, and if he replicates even 80% of his Vikings magic, he’ll silence doubters for good. As for McCarthy, the keys are his—now it’s about turning potential into production. Minnesota’s 2025 season hangs in the balance, and the NFL world will be watching.
Leave a comment